Historical Text
Monday, 11 January 2010
Xmas Task 3
Historical Text
Xmas Task 2
The Media Studies, Authors: O'Sullivan, Tim, Jewkes Yvonne(2004)
" Black people have largely portrayed as part of the mainstream middle class, which does not accuratley reflect the lives of many blacks who find themselves excluded from such a life in advanced capitalist societies", Page: 155
" Advertising has traditionally relied on the use of stereotypes to put across information in a format that is quick and easy for the viewer or reader to understand". Page 154
These quotes struck my eye as useful quotations to use in my Critical Investigation, as they talk about the experiences of black people in the media, and touches more upon the representations which could be connoted through this.
The Black and White Media Book. Handbook for the Study of Racism and Television. Revised Edition. Author: J.Twitchin 1992
This book concentrates on the representation of black people in the British media featuring quotes of racial biasness. An example of this can be seen in the article entitled "Black Mythologies: Representation of Black People on British Television" (Angela Barry).
Branston,Gill,Stafford Roy(2003): the Media Student's Book.London Great Britain.Routledge.
"Many men feel that the most compelling advertising respresentations of masculinity are ones that produce real levels of anxiety and inadequacy, even if male culture, with its emphasis on 'strong' silences or loud camaraderie, makes it difficult to talk about or express such feelings". Page: 382
This quote can show us the way men carry themselves and express thir emotions, which is an important aspect in modern society. Additionally it alliterates the stereotypical views of the masculne emotion and the ways where which males are represented, which could relate to my case study as it could also be looked at in a negative view, and the ways which this negative view could cause moral panic.
Black Demons: The Media's Depiction of the African American Male Criminal Stereotype. Author: Dennis Rome
"According to Stallworth (1994), young black men and women both continue to follow to patterns of slavery times".
This quote implys that it is not actually the media who create the negative label of black people, they just do their part in addressing the nation; as that is the job of the news. Instead it implies that the people who put themselves under the negative spotlight are to blaim for the negative view they the y inflict apon themselves. This quote could be useful additionally, as it takes a different angle as to why there is such media panic about black people, and who actually creates it.
Sunday, 10 January 2010
Xmas Task 1.
Sunday, 3 January 2010
Xmas Task 5: Essay Plan
Introduction:
In this paragraph, I intend to introduce the title of my Critical investigation, and to briefly explain the concept behind it, and what I aim to find from it. I will also explain what a moral panic is. I will briefly touch upon the platform that I am going to be focusing my research on, and why I have chosen this platform (Print Production)
1st Paragraph:
In my 1st paragraph, I aim to discuss the history of knife crime, and its origins, throwing in a couple of statistics as to when it were at its peak etc. Additionally I will be referring to several online articles which can be said to have caused moral panic over the issue, such as poverty and cultural deprivation being the main source and reason for violence amongst teens in poverty stricken areas.
2nd Paragraph:
In this paragraph, I will elaborate further on the 1st paragraph, except I will use primary evidence and sources from books as they will give a more traditional opinion as to why there is so much street violence. A quote I recently heard is that we have been this way for as long as caveman days, deemed survival of the fittest. As stated, I will touch more on the negative views on knife crime. The things i use in this paragraph, are there in order to be argued against in the next.
3rd Paragraph:
In this paragraph, I will contradict the previous paragraph, stating that knife violence is not on the increase and not such a big threat to the UK. I will use various wbsites and articles issued by the Guardian, Independant, and Daily Mail sites to support this. Additionally, I aim to discuss the similarities between the texts, and base the next paragraph on that.
4th Paragraph:
In this paragraph, I aim to assess fully the extent of how bad knife crime has become, and whether it is correct to cause a moral panic about it in order to publicise the full extent of he problem, or it is wrong, and that the media should handle things in a completely different manner. I will use various theories to support my argument (Marxism, Cultivation Theories etc).
Conclusion:
In this paragraph, I will summarise the rest of my essay, coming to a rounded conclusion.
Xmas Task 4: Additional Web Research
http://www.aber.ac.uk/media/Students/hrb9701.html
MORAL PANIC
"If we do not take steps to preserve the purity of blood, the Jew will destroy civilisation by poisoning us all". (Hitler, 1938)
Famous quote made by Hitler in 1938. Important relation to my chosen case study as it shows the impact and levels of moral panic which can be broadcasted to audiences. This quote had inevitably caused the whole of Germany to despise and hate jews; later resulting in the acceptance of the holocaust.
If on person can justify the use of a knife upon another being, and get away without being proseecuted, it can therefore be acceptable for another to find a way out.. Therefore making the sheer cruelty of stabbings being numbed, and contrast in a wave of social acceptance.
MORAL PANIC ON KNIFE CRIME
Revealed: The truth about knife crime - it has soared by 35 per cent in some parts of Britain
This isn't actually a quote, but a newspaper heading, which is obviously eye-catching in order to gain the public eye, but can tend to cause a mass moral panic in the process. Stating the truth about knife crime tends to suggest that what is in this issue is new exclusive statistics which have'nt been mentioned in past editions or other newspapers. Lastly, because of the statistic included in the title (soared by up to 35% in some parts of Britain) the paper may come across more believable as a result; however generalised it actually is (soared by 35% in SOME PARTS of Britain). Therefore a moral panic can be unintentionally created, just by the wording used to publicise the paper.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/crime/article4269818.ece
MORAL PANIC ON KNIFE CRIME
Knife crime to replace terror as police priority (July 5th, 2008)
"Knife crime has overtaken terrorism as the No 1 priority for the Metropolitan Police, one of Britain’s most senior officers said yesterday".
This is another newspaper title which had caught my eye, and the main reason for this is the date where which it were issued. This were published almost exactly a year after the 7/7 bombings took place in London, so we'd presume that the main concern in London and Britain as a whole would be to try and prevent any more of these happenings from taking place; therefore it is quite suprising to see that one Britains most senior officers can announce this on behalf of the London police.
This can ultimately cause a widespread of panic, because of the sheer volume of knife crimes committed, and further emphasise this in the way which terrorism has been 'replaced' in the number one concern of he Met.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1159766/Cartoon-violence-makes-children-aggressive.html
ARTICLES ON CHILDHOOD AGGRESSION
'There is ample evidence that physical aggression on TV is associated with increases in aggressive behaviour, but there was little until this study that has shown a link between televised aggression and resulting aggression among children.'
I found this an interesting debate; courtesy of The Daily Mail website. Reporter Laura Clark states that there is too much violence found in children, and that it is a result of violence in children shows such as cartoons. She argues that cartoons are said to be rated 'fantasy violence' which can make the parents of these viewers feel that it is acceptable for their child to view these shows without their guidance. Additionally, in the article there was a survey on the most popular cartoons viewed amongst 95 10year olds. The results received were shocking, stating that the shows aimed at younger viewers were infact the most violent, having near 26 acts of violence whereas those aimed post14 were 5. This can cause a moral panic, because it can portray that perhaps we are the reason to blaim for knife crimes acceptability amongst teens.
http://www.ehow.com/about_4570679_does-poverty-cause-crime.html
Poverty and its influence on violence
'Realistic and reachable role models are far and few between, if any exist at all, which causes the children of those who live in these areas to look up to more unsavory figures who are living the high life through low living'.
I found that this was the most touchy and awkward topic to research, as it had very little quotes or articles touched upon by the major newspapers. From what i did find however, and from what we'd expect, violence in rural areas are mainly influenced or as a result of poverty; whether it be street muggings or gang killings for money. This quote drew my eye as it states that there are no real role models in an estate or 'neighbourhood', and as i have lived in an estate, i can say that this is relatively true. The role models are either the gang leaders who inflictpoverty on others for they're own benefits, or the drug dealers who become successful in what they do and gain respect from it. This as a result can come across to children as correct and acceptable, making them aspire to be like this. 'Why make money legally, when you can make it tax-free?'.
Saturday, 26 December 2009
Xmas Task 1 Part 2: Knife crime doubles in 2 years
The Sunday Times
August 19, 2007
Colour Coded
Representation and stereotyping;
Media effects;
News Values (Statistics);
Moral Panics;
The full extent of Britain’s violent crime epidemic, which yesterday claimed the life of another teenager, is revealed in shocking new figures that show the number of street robberies involving knives has more than doubled in two years.
Attacks in which a knife was used in a successful mugging have soared, from 25,500 in 2005 to 64,000 in the year to April 2007. The figures mean that each day last year saw, on average, 175 robberies at knife-point in England and Wales – up from 110 the year before and from 69 in 2004-5.
The study, by the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies (CCJS) at King’s College London, is based on the government’s own statistics. It shows that knives are used in one in five muggings, twice the frequency reported two years ago. The new figures will renew pressure on ministers to address the rising tide of violence and antisocial behaviour on Britain’s streets.
The surge in knife crime was highlighted yesterday when police announced a murder investigation after Andrew Holland, 16, died following a stabbing in Bolton. The teenager was awaiting his GCSE results this week and wanted to join the army, his family said.
In a separate attack, Northum-bria police charged a man after an incident on the Tyne Bridge in which a policeman was allegedly attacked with a knife.
This weekend David Davis, the shadow home secretary, said ministers had been complacent.
“This explosion in knife crime is the most astounding symptom of Britain’s broken society. The government has been slow to recognise and even slower to act to deal with this plague on the streets of our towns and cities,” said Davis.
Richard Garside, director of the CCJS, said ministers had taken the wrong approach to tackling the problem. “The government has embarked on endless law and order initiatives, yet knife-related robberies appear to be increasing, if the latest figures are to be believed,” he said.
“This challenges the notion that there is a policing or punishment solution to this problem. Success in tackling knife-related violence will require a concerted strategy to deal with the causes of violence, of which the social antagonisms caused by poverty and inequality are key.”
According to the study, to be published next month, there were 320,000 robberies in the 12 months to April 2007. That contrasts with 311,000 last year and 255,000 in 2005.
The number of knife-related muggings seems to be rising rapidly despite a spate of new laws and amnesties.
Earlier this year the government increased the penalty for carrying a knife in public from two to four years’ imprisonment. But the Tories complained that ministers, including Jacqui Smith, the home secretary, had voted against a proposed increase two years before.
Of the 820 homicides in 2005 in England and Wales, 236 – or 29% – were with a knife or other sharp instrument. Those figures showed that knives are used in 6% of all violent crimes.
Critics have accused the government of lacking a coherent strategy to tackle the problem and of resorting to knee-jerk legislative responses.
A Home Office spokesman said: “Public protection is our top priority, which is why we have recently introduced tough legislation such as increasing the maximum sentence for carrying a knife in public without good reason from two to four years.”
Ministers will hope that the latest figures are a blip rather than the reversal of a downward trend since 1995.
Enver Soloman, the CCJS’s deputy director, said there needed to be more research into the problem. “There is no doubt there are more kids carrying knives, but it’s not clear why,” he said.
“Much of it is for personal safety rather than for putting it against someone’s throat.” The new report, which analyses figures in the British Crime Survey, concludes: “Since it’s extremely difficult if not impossible to limit the availability of knives, and knives are merely a tool used in violent crime, success in fighting knife crime will only come with success in dealing with the underlying causes of violence, fear and insecurity.”
Bernard Hogan-Howe, chief constable of Merseyside, yesterday described the increase as “massive” and said police are struggling to cope with the sheer volume of alcohol-fuelled youth crime.
This article was taken from the Times newspaper, issued on the 19th August 2007. The article is about the increase in knife crime, and how the government and the police are trying their best to stiop it from continuing in the way which it is.
The way in which the piece in put across could cause a great deal of moral panic through the statistics, and various opinions broadcasted throughout the review; An example of this being: -The government has been slow to recognise and even slower to act to deal with this plague on the streets of our towns and cities,” said Davis.-. The ways in which this could cause panic are multiple, the least obvious, but most effective is the way that the government are said to be unaware of the effects of knife crime. This is important, as in this society, the government are those who make the rules and inforce changes. If they can not see what is happening on the streets, then it is almost impossible for change, or to make a stop.
Another interesting quote i found was made by Richard Garside (director of the CCJS (Center for Crime and Justice Studies) in Kings College) stating: “The government has embarked on endless law and order initiatives, yet knife-related robberies appear to be increasing, if the latest figures are to be believed,”. This shows that when the government do their part in making changes to restrict knife crime from spreading, they make it worse, and this is an obvious causer of moral panic as it shows that the goverment are in fact no more or less powerful than the public.
This can all be related into Marxism, as it shows how the public are dependant on the upper classed; or in this case the government, to make changes in society. It also reiterates the fact that us as consumers of the media, are meerly pawns in a game of chess where which the government test their rules upon, and watch down on us wen we are in trouble. As pawns, we look up to the government in the hope that they will make the right choices; us being the lower classed.
Sunday, 20 December 2009
Xmas Task 1 on "An investigation into the medias role in generating the ongoing moral panic in Britain surrounding knife crime"
There are two major problems with the current debate about knife crime. The first is that national politicians are seeking to solve what ought to be a problem for the Metropolitan Police – a number of unconnected murders, mostly in London – and misrepresenting that problem in the process as an expression of general social breakdown.
The second is that a genuine and much wider moral malaise is being discussed and interpreted through the prism of this localised crime problem, distorting the nature of that malaise.
As members of the Institute of Ideas’ Education Forum recently noted, the high profile given to knives by politicians and the national media has led to politically-motivated campaigns in schools where knife crime is simply not a problem. This strategy risks having the perverse effect of normalising and glamorising the carrying of knives (”Everyone else has got one: where’s yours?”)
In a paper published by the Institute of Ideas in 2005, sociologist Stuart Waiton coined the term ˜amoral panic’ to describe situations in which the panic is less about a perceived threat to social mores than anxiety about the absence of any moral consensus to be threatened.
Characteristically, such panics give rise to awareness campaigns and authoritarian gimmicks like curfews, rather than any attempt to address hard moral questions, which indeed often have little to do with the particular issue in the news.
The willingness of the political class to see a localised problem with knife crime as emblematic of a “broken society”, and then to offer technical fixes, is testament to a failure of the moral imagination.
Today’s politicians may be unable to resist the temptation to bundle these two very different problems together. A real moral and political lead would mean leaving knife crime to the police, and offering a political vision capable of inspiring all of us rather than keeping the kids off the streets.
.jpg)